Is Private Tutoring Really Essential? What the UK Data Shows

Is Private Tutoring Really Essential? What the UK Data Shows Updated 19-September-2026

"Essential" is a strong word, and it is worth asking whether it is accurate or just familiar marketing language before repeating it. The honest answer, based on the most current UK data available, is more specific and more interesting than a blanket yes: private tutoring has become close to the norm in some parts of the country, while remaining genuinely out of reach for a persistent share of families who could benefit from it most.

How Common Is Private Tutoring in the UK, Really?

The Sutton Trust's 2026 research found that 29 percent of secondary pupils in England and Wales have received private tutoring at some point, up from 18 percent two decades ago and slightly higher than the 27 percent recorded in 2019. That national figure, though, hides a striking regional pattern directly relevant to East London families: 45 percent of London pupils have received private tutoring, compared with 27 percent in the rest of England and 24 percent in Wales. In London specifically, tutoring is no longer a fringe extra used by a minority; it is closer to a majority norm among secondary pupils, which changes the honest framing of the question from "is tutoring essential" to "most families in this city already think so, and here is why."

The Access Gap "Essential" Framing Glosses Over

The same research is equally clear about who is being left out. Only 23 percent of pupils from the most disadvantaged households have received private tutoring, compared with 30 percent from wealthier families, a gap that has barely narrowed since 2019 despite years of public conversation about closing attainment gaps. This has been made worse, not better, recently: 58 percent of state schools reported reducing their tutoring provision compared with the previous year, a decline the Sutton Trust links directly to the end of the government-funded National Tutoring Programme, covered in more depth in our guide to online tuition. School-based tutoring was often the only route into this kind of support for lower-income families, so its decline widens the very gap "essential" framing tends to gloss over.

Why This Gap Matters More Than a Marketing Claim

This is not a purely abstract equity point. The Education Endowment Foundation's own review of one-to-one tuition specifically notes that pupils eligible for free school meals show particularly strong benefits from this kind of targeted, individual academic support, meaning the pupils least likely to currently access tutoring are, on the evidence, among those most likely to gain the most from it. That makes the access gap a genuine missed opportunity rather than simply an unfortunate statistic.

One Honest Caution Before You Choose a Format

As AI-based tutoring tools have proliferated, the Sutton Trust has explicitly cautioned against treating them as an equivalent substitute for human tutoring, warning that "the evidence is not there yet" for their effectiveness and flagging a real risk of a new kind of divide, where wealthier families continue to access human, small-group or one-to-one support while lower-income families are steered toward lower-cost AI alternatives with a considerably thinner evidence base. This is a genuinely useful caution for any family currently weighing up tutoring options, not a self-serving one: the evidence-backed formats covered in our guide to one-to-one versus small-group tuition remain human-led for exactly this reason.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is private tutoring really "essential" for academic success in the UK?

The evidence does not support a universal claim like that. What it does show is that tutoring has become the norm for a majority of London secondary pupils specifically, and that pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds, who access it least, often stand to gain the most from it.

How common is private tutoring in London specifically?

The Sutton Trust's 2026 research found 45 percent of London secondary pupils have received private tutoring at some point, nearly double the rate in rural parts of England and considerably higher than the 27 percent national average for the rest of England.

Has the gap between advantaged and disadvantaged pupils' access to tutoring improved?

Only slightly. Access for disadvantaged pupils rose from 21 percent in 2019 to 23 percent in 2025, while access for wealthier pupils rose from 28 percent to 30 percent over the same period, meaning the gap has remained largely unchanged.

Should I use an AI tutoring tool instead of a human tutor?

The Sutton Trust explicitly cautions against treating AI tutoring as an evidence-equivalent substitute for human tutoring, noting the evidence base is not yet established and warning of a risk that AI becomes a lower-cost, lower-evidence option offered disproportionately to families who cannot access human tutoring.

Sources: